How to Give Notes on an AI Vertical Drama Rough Cut When Your Commissioning Team Has No Film Background

The rough cut arrives. Eight episodes, a review link, a deadline for notes. The commissioning team watches on a laptop, agrees something feels off in episode three, and cannot say what. The notes that go back read like reactions rather than instructions. The production partner guesses, revises the wrong thing, and the second cut lands with the same problem plus a new one.

This is one of the most common friction points on a first commission. It has nothing to do with taste or intelligence. Brand teams, platform content leads, marketing managers and IP owners are often sharp judges of what works with an audience. What they lack is a shared vocabulary with the people who cut and generate the picture, and a method for turning a feeling into a note. This guide gives a commissioning team both, without asking anyone to become an editor.

1. Understand What a Rough Cut Is and Is Not

A rough cut is an assembly of the story in order, built from the best available material, with timing roughly set and finishing work still to come. The rough cut stage in film editing has always been the moment where structure is judged before polish is applied. On an AI vertical drama production the principle holds. Story, performance and pacing are on the table. Final colour, final sound mix, subtitles and some generated shots may still be placeholders.

Knowing this changes what a commissioning team should look at. A rough cut is not the place to flag that the music is temporary or that a lower third is missing. Those items are already on the production checklist. It is the place to ask whether the story lands, whether the hook in the first seconds of each episode holds, and whether the cliffhanger at the end of each episode earns the next tap.

What is usually still unfinished at this stage

Most production partners will state what is provisional when they send the cut. If they do not, ask. Typical placeholders include temporary score, rough dialogue levels, ungraded picture, burned in timecode, and occasional shots marked for regeneration. A team that knows the list in advance stops spending notes on things that will change anyway.

What is fixed enough to judge

Episode order, scene order, the length of each episode, which moments are shown and which are withheld, and how each character comes across. These are the decisions that are expensive to reverse later. They are also the decisions a commissioning team is best placed to judge, because they sit closest to the audience and the brief.

2. Watch It the Way the Audience Will

Many first notes are wrong because the cut was watched on the wrong screen. A vertical drama is built for a phone held at arm length, often with the sound low or off for the first seconds, often between other things. Watching on a widescreen monitor in a meeting room with good speakers hides the problems an audience will meet and invents problems they never will.

Set a simple rule for the first pass. Every reviewer watches on a phone, in portrait, at normal volume, alone. Watch each episode once without pausing. Then write down, in one line per episode, what you felt and where. Only after that first pass should anyone go back with the pause button.

The first pass captures attention, not detail

The first pass is about drop off points. Where did your thumb want to swipe away. Where did you lose track of who someone was. Where did the episode end and you felt nothing pull you forward. Those moments are the most valuable data a commissioning team can give a production partner, because they mirror what retention data will later show on the platform.

The second pass finds the cause

On the second pass, go back to each flagged moment and look closer. Is the problem a line of dialogue, a shot that holds too long, a reveal that comes too early, a face that does not read as the same character, or a scene that seems to be missing. You do not need the technical term. You need the timestamp and a plain description of what happens on screen.

3. Separate Story Notes From Picture Notes

The most useful thing a commissioning team can do is sort its notes into two groups before sending them. Story notes concern what happens, in what order, and why the audience should care. Picture notes concern how a specific shot looks. These go to different people on the production side and are solved in different ways.

A story note might be that the audience learns the sister is lying too early, so the tension in episode four has nowhere to go. That note goes to the director and the editor, and may touch the script. A picture note might be that the lead character looks older in one close up in episode two. That note goes to the generation and quality review team, and is usually solved by regenerating a shot against the character reference.

Why mixing them causes slow revisions

When story and picture notes are mixed in one long list, the production team has to triage them before anyone can act. Priorities get lost. A small picture fix gets done fast while a structural story problem waits, and the second cut looks cleaner while still failing in the same place. Sorting the notes on the commissioning side removes a full step from the loop.

A simple way to sort

Ask one question of every note. If this were fixed, would the shot look different, or would the story feel different. Look different means picture. Feel different means story. Some notes will be both, and that is fine. Put them in the story group, because story decisions should lead.

4. Write Notes That Describe the Problem, Not the Solution

The instinct of a non specialist is often to propose a fix. Cut this scene. Add a close up. Make her angrier. Sometimes the fix is right. Often it is not, because the cause of the problem sits somewhere else in the episode. A note that describes the effect gives the production team room to find the right cause.

Compare two notes on the same moment. The first says to cut the kitchen scene in episode five. The second says that at the kitchen scene in episode five, at the forty second mark, the episode loses energy and it is unclear what the scene adds. The second note may still lead to the scene being cut. It may also lead to it being shortened, moved, or rewritten to carry information the audience is missing. The commissioning team has stated what it experienced. The production team decides how.

The four part note

A note that a production partner can act on without a call usually has four parts. Where, meaning the episode and the timestamp. What happens on screen, in plain words. What the reviewer felt or understood. What the reviewer expected to feel or understand instead. That last part is the one most often missing, and it is the one that turns a reaction into a target.

When you do have a specific fix in mind

Say so, but mark it as a suggestion. A phrase such as one possible fix is, or we wonder whether, signals that the note is open. Production teams generally welcome ideas from the commissioning side, especially on character and audience. They work best when the idea arrives alongside the problem it is meant to solve.

5. Use a Small Shared Vocabulary

A commissioning team does not need a film glossary. It needs about a dozen words that remove ambiguity. Agree them internally before the first cut arrives, and share the list with the production partner so both sides use them the same way.

A handful that do most of the work:

  • Hook, meaning the opening seconds of an episode that must hold attention before anything else happens.

  • Beat, meaning a single moment of change in a scene, such as a reveal, a decision or a reaction.

  • Reveal, meaning the moment the audience learns something new.

  • Button, meaning the final moment of an episode that creates the pull to the next.

  • Hold, meaning a shot that stays on screen longer than the moment needs.

  • Read, meaning whether something is understood at a glance on a phone.

  • Continuity, meaning whether a character, prop or place stays the same from shot to shot.

These words map directly onto how editors and directors think about a vertical episode. A note that says the button on episode six does not read lands faster than a note that says the ending is a bit flat. It points at a specific moment and a specific failure.

Words to avoid

Vague words create revision loops. Flat, off, weird, not quite there, and missing something all describe a feeling without a location. They are useful on the first pass as private markers. They should not appear in the final notes document without a timestamp and an expected outcome attached.

6. Consolidate Before You Send

The single biggest cause of slow revisions on a first commission is contradictory notes. Marketing wants the romance pushed harder. Legal wants a scene softened. The content lead wants the villain more sympathetic. Each note is reasonable. Together they pull the cut in three directions, and the production partner cannot resolve the conflict because it does not own the brief.

Appoint one person on the commissioning side to own the notes document. That person collects every reviewer input, removes duplicates, resolves contradictions internally, and sends one document. If a conflict cannot be resolved inside the commissioning team, it is flagged as an open question in the document rather than sent as two opposing instructions.

Order the notes by consequence

Within the consolidated document, put the notes that would change the most first. Episode order and structural story notes at the top. Character and performance notes next. Picture and continuity notes after that. Small polish observations last, clearly marked as low priority. This ordering tells the production partner where to spend its first hours, and it keeps the expensive decisions from being buried.

Agree the notes deadline and the number of rounds in advance

A production schedule assumes a fixed number of review rounds. Every extra round costs time and money somewhere. The feedback rhythm with a production partner should be agreed at kickoff, so the commissioning team knows how many chances it has and treats each one as final for its scope.

7. Know Which Notes Are Cheap and Which Are Expensive on an AI Production

On an AI native production, the cost of a note depends on where in the pipeline it lands. Some changes are made in the edit with existing material and cost almost nothing. Some require regenerating a handful of shots against existing references. Some require going back to the script, the shot plan and the generation queue for an entire sequence.

A commissioning team that understands this can spend its notes wisely. It does not need to know the tools. It needs a rough sense of three tiers.

Edit level changes

Trimming a hold, reordering two shots, tightening a scene, moving a reveal earlier or later within existing material, swapping a take. These are usually the fastest and lightest changes. A large share of pacing and hook problems can be solved here.

Shot level changes

Regenerating a shot because a face drifted, a prop changed, a hand looks wrong, or an eyeline does not match. These are routine on an AI production and are handled by the generation and quality review team. They take more effort than an edit change but stay contained to the shots involved.

Sequence level changes

Rewriting a scene, adding a scene that was never planned, changing a character arc, or altering the location of a sequence. These ripple through the script, the shot plan, the generation order and the edit. They are possible, but they belong in the first round of notes, not the last, and they may carry a cost conversation.

When a commissioning team flags a note as sequence level in the first round, it gives the production partner the best chance to absorb the change inside the agreed schedule. When the same note arrives in the final round, it becomes a change request.

8. Close the Loop on the Second Cut

Notes are only half the review. The other half is checking that the revised cut addressed them. Return the consolidated notes document to the production partner with a status column, and ask the partner to mark each note as addressed, addressed differently, or open with a reason. Then review the second cut against that document rather than starting fresh.

This prevents two common problems. The first is new notes appearing on material that was already approved, which resets progress. The second is a note that was solved in a different way than expected being re raised because nobody remembered the original problem. Reviewing against the document keeps everyone anchored to what was asked and why.

When a note was solved differently

Judge the result against the problem, not against the suggested fix. If the original note said the audience learns the lie too early, and the production team solved it by changing a line of dialogue rather than cutting a scene, ask only whether the audience still learns the lie too early. If not, the note is closed. The process for evaluating a delivered series before accepting it follows the same logic at the final stage.

Axis AI Studios Perspective

Review is where a commission is won or lost. A strong script and a capable production team can still deliver a weak series if the notes loop is noisy, late or contradictory. A commissioning team that sorts its notes, describes problems rather than prescribing fixes, and sends one consolidated document per round usually gets a better second cut than a team with far more film experience and less discipline.

Axis AI Studios builds its review process around this. Each rough cut arrives with a clear list of what is provisional, so commissioning teams spend their attention on story, character and pacing. Notes are triaged on arrival into edit, shot and sequence level work, and each note is returned with a status so the next review starts from what was asked. The aim is a review loop that a brand or platform team can run confidently on its first commission, without needing anyone on staff who has sat in an edit suite.

For commissioning teams preparing their first AI vertical drama series, or planning a slate where several teams will review cuts, the conversation starts at business@axisaistudios.com.

FAQ

How many people on the commissioning side should review a rough cut?

Enough to represent the decisions that matter, and no more. Usually that is the content or creative owner, one person close to the audience such as marketing, and anyone with sign off authority on compliance. Every reviewer feeds into one consolidated notes document owned by a single person.

Should we give notes on placeholder music, colour or subtitles at the rough cut stage?

Generally not, unless the placeholder is actively misleading you about the story. Ask the production partner for a list of provisional elements when the cut is delivered. Notes on finishing work are more useful at the fine cut or final review stage, when those elements are in place.

What if we cannot explain why an episode does not work?

Give the timestamp and describe what you felt. A note that says the reviewer stopped caring about the lead at around the thirty second mark of episode three is useful even without a diagnosis. Diagnosing the cause is the job of the production team. Locating the moment is the most valuable thing the commissioning team can do.

Further Reading

For teams that want to agree the review cadence before the first cut arrives, the guide to setting a feedback rhythm with a production partner covers how to schedule notes so they land while changes are still inexpensive.

For reviewers who want to understand why pacing notes matter so much in a vertical format, the breakdown of pacing and cut rhythm in vertical drama editing covers how editors build tension shot by shot for a phone screen.

For commissioning teams approaching final delivery, the checklist for evaluating your first delivered series covers what to check before signing off a completed series.

Stay connected

For studios moving beyond traditional production.

Let's set
the new standard together.

If you're working on something, we'd like to hear about it.